The Eleventh Thing

Quote from DeDe Halfhill: “The quality of our leadership depends, in part, on the quality of what we choose to notice.”

There is a strange thing we do with people we work with every day. We can know ten things they do well and yet become completely consumed by the eleventh thing that is driving us crazy.

I am exceptionally qualified to tell you this because for years my eye was trained to find the gap. The missed deadline, the error on the slide, the thing that still wasn’t done. Two decades into my Air Force career, I was very, very good at it. Heck, I’d been rewarded for it!

So when I took command of the 2nd Mission Support Group at Barksdale Air Force Base, I decided to try something deliberately different.

I looked for and started keeping track of what was great about my commanders when they were at their best.

One was so connected to his team that I could regularly see how much they trusted him. Another was in the middle of his own growth, and I watched him stay curious, keep learning, and remain open. The third had this remarkable ability to walk into a room and settle it. She knew who she was, and somehow that helped everyone around her settle into who they were too.

None of this meant I stopped seeing what needed to improve. Believe me, the Air Force had not suddenly relieved me of that responsibility.

I was simply making sure the problems weren’t the only evidence I was collecting.

Why Leaders Notice What Went Wrong First

There’s a reason this takes some effort.

Roy Baumeister and his colleagues reviewed decades of research for their paper, Bad Is Stronger Than Good, and found the pattern across an enormous range of human experience: negative information tends to receive more attention and processing than positive information.

That matters at work because leaders spend a lot of time reviewing what went wrong or looking for what might.

Negativity bias at work means the missed deadline gets a leader’s attention and the three problems someone solved before lunch barely register. Leaders spend much of their time reviewing what went wrong, so over months the problems become most of what they know about a person. Then they lead from that incomplete picture, and it decides how much they trust that person, what they hand them, and how they read the next mistake.

How Frustration Changes Who a Leader Trusts

There’s another piece of research I find fascinating here.

Jennifer Dunn and Maurice Schweitzer ran five experiments to see whether our emotions can change how much we trust someone, even when that person had nothing to do with how we were feeling.

They found that people who were feeling grateful were more likely to trust someone. People who were feeling angry were less likely to trust them.

But the most interesting part is that the effect mostly went away when people understood where their feelings were actually coming from or they knew the other person really well.

I don’t take that to mean gratitude makes us objective. It doesn’t.

I take it as another reminder that what is happening inside us can become part of how we interpret what is happening around us.

Which makes me think differently about the list I kept all those years ago.

I wasn’t trying to convince myself my commanders were wonderful. I certainly wasn’t lowering the standard. I was forcing myself to keep collecting evidence so that the weight of frustration wasn’t unfairly tipping the scale.

Sometimes someone really is underperforming and sometimes trust has been damaged. And, sometimes a team has checked out and a leader needs to deal with it.

But you want to know that is what you are actually seeing.

The leaders who wrote the Air Force’s first leadership manual were remarkably direct about this. They told leaders that their “sympathetic interest and concern” for their people had to come from the heart. It couldn’t be mechanical. They understood that how a leader saw people shaped the relationship that followed.

By the end of my command tour, I loved those commanders for who they were. I still do.

I don’t think that happened because I ignored their shortcomings.

I think I got better at seeing the whole person. And that changed the kind of leader I could be with them.

One Thing to Try This Week

Pull up your team roster and spend ten minutes writing down one thing each person does exceptionally well that you have stopped noticing.

And if you want to make this exercise really useful, start with the person who has frustrated you most this year.

You don’t have to change your standards. You don’t have to manufacture gratitude. Just make sure frustration hasn’t become the only evidence you’re collecting.

The quality of our leadership depends, in part, on the quality of what we choose to notice.

P.S. This is the work I do in keynotes and leadership sessions with teams who want to see their people more completely.

Blog
DeDe Halfhill speaking on stage in a magenta blazer, with the words "The Question You Dismiss"

The Question You Think Is a Waste of Time

DeDe Halfhill seated, with the words "A third of feedback backfires"

The Words Were Never the Problem

DeDe Halfhill speaking in a blue blazer, with the words "Version 387 Looks Like Discipline"

Discipline